Top 10 Best New York City SEO Companies for 2023

Are you looking for the best New York City SEO companies?

You’re in the right place. Our independent rankings give you the lowdown on which agencies are the best in the City and why.

Our rankings use third-party, independent data. So you can be sure you’re getting transparent information. Then, having collated and analyzed the data, we make it easy for you to find the right New York City SEO company for your business.

Free SEO Agency Finder – Use our free service to find an agency or consultant that will actually deliver SEO results.

You can find our ranking criteria below. In the meantime, take a look at these New York City SEO companies that can put your business on the map.

Top 10 Best New York City SEO Companies for 2023

  1. Main Street ROI (28 points)
  2. SEO Services New York (25 points)
  3. Mimvi SEO LLC (25 points)
  4. Ironpaper Marketing (24 points)
  5. Path Interactive (22 points)
  6. Sure Oak (22 points)
  7. Mindsaw (22 points)
  8. Top Notch Dezigns (21 points)
  9. Four Dots (21 points)
  10. HTML Pro (21 points)

1. Main Street ROI

High domain authority and over 250 outstanding reviews ensure Main Street ROI pip competitors to the post when it comes to being the best SEO agency in New York City 2023. The firm specializes in working with small businesses and delivering local search engine optimization services.

Main Street ROI

If you’re a startup or a growing business based in NYC, it’s well worth looking at what Main Street ROI can offer. Their mission is to ‘help small businesses thrive, regardless of their budgets.’

Main Street ROI also has an educational side of the business, which teaches digital marketing.

But that’s not all:

Their monthly search engine optimization fees start at $500, although you can opt for a one-off search engine optimization audit for $300. With custom strategies and budgets, businesses across all industries can find valuable guidance, support, and search engine optimization with Main Street ROI.

2. SEO Services New York

Founded in 2009, SEO Services New York has 113 search engine optimization campaigns to its name and has attracted interest from Clutch, Agency Spotter, and TDA, amongst others. And their rankings make sense since they’ve received an array of awards.

SEO Services New York

Despite having a low number of DoFollow links pointing towards the site, their stellar reviews and impressive total traffic figures ensure search engine optimization Services New York remains one of the best SEO companies in New York City.

Delivering PPC, search engine optimization, content marketing, and consultancy and training, you can outsource your digital marketing services to their in-house team or request that they share their expertise with your own staff. SEO Services New York works with local, national, and international brands.

3. Mimvi SEO LLC

Delivering ‘SEO That Works,’ Mimvi SEO rank well because of high domain authority, a decent number of DoFollow links, fast page speeds, excellent site security, and positive feedback from their clients.

Mimvi SEO

Potential clients can benefit from an SEO audit, so it’s an excellent opportunity to gain feedback from their in-house team and decide whether their strategies are right for you. Guiding clients through website design, search engine optimization, PPC ad campaigns, and online reputation management, they offer a comprehensive range of services that can benefit any business.

With a heavy emphasis on local SEO, Mimvi search engine optimization positions itself as specialist within the NYC and Long Island regions. Therefore, for brands based within these areas or businesses that want to target these geographical locations, Mimvi could be the ideal growth partner.

4. Ironpaper Marketing

Specializing in search engine optimization, Ironpaper Marketing is a full-service SEO agency that can complement effective search engine optimization with a range of other services. From content marketing and lead generation to web design and conversion optimization, you can access everything you need to grow your business under one roof.


Their in-house team of marketers, analysts, engineers, and writers focus on Analytics, Agility, and Action to secure results on behalf of clients. Finessing the customer’s journey by aligning sales and marketing strategies, a data-driven approach is behind every decision and action taken.

Founded by Jonathan Franchell in 2003, the team consists of over 30 in-house specialists working from two locations: NYC and Charlotte. Having achieved a 3000% lead increase for a B2B company, a 716% quarter-on-quarter increase in qualified leads for a telecom management firm, and a 500% increase in sales for a non-profit organization, it’s clear Ironpaper Marketing offers impressive results across a range of sectors.

Clocking in with the highest domain authority in our top 10, a high rate of traffic, and a staggering number of DoFollow links, they’ve earned the right as one of the best SEO companies in New York City.

5. Path Interactive

If you’re looking for a search engine optimization company with credentials, Path Interactive will catch your eye. As well as being a Google Premier Partner, the firm is a Bing Ads Accredited Professional and a Facebook Marketing Partner, as well as accreditation with Salesforce, Marin Software, and Conductor.

Path Interactive

Furthermore, members of their management team deliver industry-leading education via the New York University School of Continuing and Professional Studies. Also, Path Interactive provides corporate training programs in social media and SEO, so you can ensure your in-house team shares their skills, talents, and expertise.

With so many strings to their bow, it’s easy to see why Path Interactive is one of the best SEO companies in New York City. They offer search engine optimization, paid search, display, digital media, social media, creative strategy, design and development, analytics, and Amazon marketing services as a full-service firm.

6. Sure Oak

Also securing their place in the rankings with 22 points, Sure Oak positions themselves as ‘A New York SEO Agency for Bold Dreamers.’ Located in the Flatiron District, Sure Oak offers a wide range of search engine optimization services.

Everything you need to improve your Google rankings is offered in-house as part of their search engine optimization package, from technical audits and advanced keyword research to competitor analysis, content optimization, and link building (for search engines).

Sure Oak

With case studies reporting 582% growth in organic traffic via link building and on-site optimization, page 1 rankings for 17 competitive terms for one client, and a 538% increase in organic traffic in just two months, new clients can look forward to the same level of service and comparable results.

But you don’t have to become a paid-up customer to see what Sure Oak can offer. They feature free search engine optimization tools on their website, so you can analyze your web pages, check your domain authority, and generate meta tags to gain more insight into your current rankings and what you need to do to improve them.

7. Mindsaw

Another SEO company that achieved 22 points in our unbiased rankings is Mindsaw. Committed to ‘Helping Your Business Grow, ‘ Mindsaw falls somewhere between a bespoke New York SEO company and a full-service firm. They also have an in-house logo design, video marketing, website design, and social media marketing.


Plus, Mindsaw offers dedicated local search engine optimization services and packages aimed at small businesses. If you want to grow your company or are targeting particular geographical locations, these specialisms could help you to achieve your goals in a short amount of time.

Mindsaw earned its place with stellar on-site search engine optimization, high domain authority, and an array of outstanding client reviews. If you’re eager to see why so many clients rate them, they offer a free telephone consultation so that you can find out more without any pressure.

8. Top Notch Dezigns

Taking a multi-channel approach to digital marketing, Top Notch Dezigns is a full-service New York SEO company that aims to optimize conversions and gain brand loyalty.

Top Notch Dezigns

Founded in 2004, the firm has over 15 years of experience in the industry and has expanded its services to provide top-quality digital marketing to a range of clients. Hailed as a Top Web Designer by Clutch in 2018 and receiving three awards from Design Rush in the same year, Top Notch Dezigns has also been a winning recipient of the Davey Awards.

Whether you’re looking for branding, app development, web design, or pure optimization for search engines, their range of services ensures they’re well-placed to provide the expertise, tools, and talent your business needs.

9. Four Dots

Receiving 21 points in our rankings, Four Dots specializes in helping small to medium-sized businesses attract wider audiences and increase their online exposure. With over 60 in-house specialists, this New York SEO company has content creators, strategists, and technical experts on hand to create effective campaigns on behalf of their clients.

Four Dots

Their search engine optimization services include blogger outreach engagement, backlink analysis, and Google penalty removal. Four Dots’ also offers online reputation management, PPC ad management, website design, and content creation.

Offering free SEM tools and their very own Academy, Four Dots doesn’t just provide you with great results; they give you the knowledge, tools, and expertise you need to achieve them yourself.

10. HTML Pro

As HTML Pro slides into our top 10, also receiving 21 points, it’s clear how much competition there is amongst the best SEO companies in New York City for 2023. As the name suggests, HTML Pro is a web design and development agency, although they’ve broadened their specialties to include a range of other services.


They also provide social media marketing, paid advertising, graphic design, app development, and a range of IT solutions. So if you’re looking for a New York SEO company that can design, create, and maintain your website, they might be a good fit for you.

As well as being an accredited Google Partner, HTML Pro is an UpCity Certified Partner and Shopify Partner, so you can rely on their credentials when it comes to boosting your Google rankings and performance.

With dedicated services for small businesses and a range of on and off-page search engine optimization tools at their disposal, HMTL Pro offers all the web, IT, and search engine optimization solutions a company could need.

Scoring Criteria

To ensure our rankings are independent, unbiased, and verifiable, we use data that are available to the public to collate a score for each company. Assessing elements that impact rankings, we look at six broad categories and give each company a score of 1-5 for each category.

The elements used within each category include:

  • Loading speeds
  • Domain authority
  • Number of Google reviews
  • Average Google review score
  • Site Security
  • Whether the website is mobile-friendly
  • Total traffic to the site
  • Number of do-follow links pointing to the site

The maximum number of points a company can get is 30. So as you can see, our top SEO company in New York City soared to the top of our rankings with an impressive 28 out of 30 points.

Start sending inquiries today

If you’re looking for the best SEO companies in New York City, this list gives you a great place to start. In a digital era, finding the right partner to increase your online profile is essential. With so many companies claiming to deliver outstanding results, it’s crucial to find a New York SEO company that can do what it claims.

To find the best fit for your brand, take a look at what each company offers, review their case studies, and get in touch to determine which ones can provide your business with the best results.

Keep learning:

Photo of author

Nathan Gotch

Nathan Gotch is an SEO professional with over 10 years of experience. He's the founder of the #1 SEO business training program in the world, Gotch SEO Academy. And the author of The SEO Entrepreneur. Nathan's SEO expertise is featured on Semrush, Ahrefs, and Search Engine Journal.